Beware the Praise Barometer!

Have you been the recipient of praise that felt lavish and insincere? Experienced teachers usually have a built-in praise barometer and know full-well when they have really accomplished something praiseworthy and when they have not. Constant praise can become background noise or, worse yet, can cause skepticism or self-doubt. When coaches use frequent or generic praise connected to tiny achievements, it can actually backfire, creating cynicism and undermining the coach’s role as a mentor. A teacher who is overly-praised for tasks that require little effort might doubt the sincerity of her coach or wonder if such praise is offered because there’s nothing more substantive to compliment. When praise is excessive or focused on trivialities, it may not be well-received and can lose its effectiveness (Bayat, 2011). Yet praise is an ingrained, Anglo-American cultural phenomenon (Quinn, 2005) – and one with many benefits, if used appropriately. Rather than choosing not to praise, co...